Adaptive radiation along ecological and morphological lines of least resistance in Cyprinodon pupfishes

Adaptive radiation results in part from ecological opportunity in a new environment, but it is unclear how pre-existing constraints in the founding population may limit this process. Genetic lines of least resistance, and by proxy morphological variance, are known to limit adaptive divergence, but ecological variance is rarely investigated. Here we test whether ecological or morphological lines of least resistance in generalist populations may have constrained the directions of species divergence in two independent Caribbean adaptive radiations of Cyprinodon pupfishes. We find almost universal congruence between the major multivariate dimensions of intraspecific craniofacial and dietary variance within generalist populations and the major axes of interspecific divergence within each adaptive radiation. This is surprising given that we document unique trophic specialists within each radiation, including a bivalve-specialist, zooplanktivore, molluscivore/ostracod-specialist, and scale-eating specialist, while nearly all generalist populations were observed to feed rarely on these same resources. We conclude that pre-existing genetic constraints within each founding generalist population, resulting in dimensions of greater ecological and morphological variance, may partially constrain and predict the directions of species divergence and dietary specialization during adaptive radiation. We also provide a new framework for examining ecological lines of least resistance.