Efficacy of natural marine sponges as a passive environmental DNA sampler for freshwater fish diversity monitoring

Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis is a cost-effective and noninvasive tool for species and biodiversity monitoring in aquatic environments. Passive eDNA sampling is a novel alternative to conventional sampling methods such as water filtration. In this study, we examined the efficacy of the sponge skeleton as a passive eDNA sampler for monitoring freshwater fish. The performance of the passive sampling method was compared with that of standard water filtration in a river environment. Five DNA extraction methods were used in three experiments, and a suitable method for DNA extraction from sponge skeleton was identified. Quantitative fish metabarcoding using MiFish primers revealed no significant differences in species richness between the aqueous and passive sampling methods. Although both the sampling methods showed comparable trends in fish community structure, different clusters were identified for water sampling and passive samplers based on the differences in the DNA concentration of each fish species. The fish diversity in the passive samples was comparable among four DNA extraction methods (except for the filtration method) using the direct capture method. Our results demonstrate the efficacy of passive eDNA sampling for monitoring freshwater fish diversity and the potential use of sponge skeletons as absorption materials for passive eDNA samplers.