Match Injury Incidence and Risk Factors in American Youth Soccer: The Elite Clubs National League Injury Data Collection Program

Objective

This study aimed to establish a nationwide data collection network in order to identify injury incidence and risk factors during competition in elite youth soccer athletes. We also sought to identify the influence of playing games on consecutive days and the inclusion of a rest day on injury risk in multi-day events.

Design

Prospective Cohort Study

Setting

Elite Clubs National League (ECNL) events with one game per day over 3 days (regular season, unlimited substitution, no rest days) or 4 days (post-season, limited substitution, rest day between games 1 and 3)

Participants

Youth soccer players

Main Outcome Measures

Injuries at events were recorded by athletic trainers regarding mechanism, type, body part, return-to-play (yes, no), game number (1-3), and time of year (regular, post-season). Comparisons between groups were made with chi-square tests and the associations of injury incidence with gender, age, game number and time of year were assessed through negative binomial regression models.

Results

806 injuries were reported from 24 events representing 200,047 player-hours. Injury incidence was 4.0 per 1000 player-hours overall and girls had a higher injury incidence than boys (4.4 v 3.5 v per 1,000 player-hours, respectively, incidence rate ratio (IRR)=1.28 [1.0-1.6], p=0.03). Concussion incidence was 0.80 per 1,000 player-hours and did not differ significantly between boys and girls (0.86 v 0.72 per 1,000 player-hours, respectively, IRR=1.28 [0.84-2.0], p=0.26). In the multivariable models, after adjusting for age and gender, injury incidence was not associated with game number (game 2 IRR=0.87 [0.73-1.0], p=0.12; game 3 IRR=0.87 [0.73-1.0], p=0.13). No significant interactions between game number and time of year (rest day or not) were identified for all injuries (Game [3] * Time (regular season) IRR=1.16 [0.65-2.1], p=0.61) or concussions only (1.25 [0.3-5.2], p=0.76).

Conclusions

Among this group of elite youth soccer players, girls had a higher overall injury incidence, but concussion incidence was similar. No increased injury incidence was identified during the later games of multi-day events when games were played on consecutive days with unlimited substitution, and injury incidence was not influenced by the inclusion of rest days. The establishment of this novel data collection framework embedded within a nationwide elite youth soccer organization will continue to inform strategies to promote safe and healthy participation in youth soccer events.

Key Points

• The incorporation of athletic trainers at youth soccer events represents an opportunity to develop a novel, nationwide data collection network to evaluate match injury characteristics, incidence and risk factors.

• Female youth soccer athletes had a higher overall injury incidence, although no difference was identified in injury mechanism, severity, or concussion incidence.

• With unlimited substitution, playing 3 full-length games on 3 consecutive days was not associated with an increased injury or concussion incidence in later games, and the incorporation of rest days in multi-day events did not appear to influence injury or concussion risk.