Balancing precision with plasticity: Redefining the roles of transcription factors in early cell fate specification

Early embryogenesis is governed by intricate gene regulatory networks that orchestrate cell fate specification across all three germ layers. While the role of transcription factors (TFs) and pioneer factors (PFs) in shaping chromatin accessibility is well established, the mechanisms coordinating spatiotemporal gene expression before gastrulation remain poorly understood. Here, we investigate how a coordinated network of early-acting regulators, including the pioneer factors Zelda (Zld), GAGA factor (GAF), and the pioneer-like timing factor Odd-paired (Opa/ZIC3), along with Dorsal (Dl), Twist (Twi), the Polycomb subunit Enhancer of Zeste (E(z)), and the co-activator CBP, govern early transcriptional events in the Drosophila embryo.

Using integrated chromatin accessibility, histone modification, TF binding, and transcriptomic data (bulk and single-cell), we identify two distinct classes of regulatory elements that govern early gene expression. The first class includes distal, PF-dependent enhancers that are inaccessible early and require PFs such as Opa and Zld to overcome Su(H) activities and H3K27me3-mediated repression and initiate transcription. The second class, enriched for PcG domains, comprises proximal enhancers that are accessible from the earliest nuclear cycles, despite being marked by H3K27me3 and bound by E(z). These regions are preloaded with RNA Polymerase II and positioned near promoters, suggesting a regulatory state primed for activation. While bound by multiple early TFs, these enhancers maintain accessibility independently of PF activity, functioning instead as autoregulatory elements that rely on PFs for maintenance rather than initiation.

This study expands our understanding of how early TFs and PFs coordinate to balance transcriptional precision and developmental plasticity across germ layers, and redefines the role of PFs as both activators and stabilizers of gene regulatory architecture. Within this framework, Opa regulates key mesodermal and neuroectodermal genes such as slp1 and odd , and its activity is modulated by Suppressor of Hairless (Su(H)). At earlier stages, Su(H) represses Opa target genes, but rising Opa levels at later timepoints override this repression, enabling activation.

Together, these findings support a dual-mode enhancer logic: one mode driven by PF-mediated chromatin opening at distal, repressed enhancers, and another where proximal, pre-accessible enhancers within PcG-marked regions are reinforced by PF binding. This study redefines the role of PFs in early development, emphasizing their maintenance and stabilizing roles at poised enhancers, and provides a framework for how embryos balance transcriptional plasticity with spatial precision across all germ layers.