The global demand and potential public health impact of oral antiviral treatment stockpile for influenza pandemics
This article has been Reviewed by the following groups
Discuss this preprint
Start a discussion What are Sciety discussions?Listed in
- Evaluated articles (Rapid Reviews Infectious Diseases)
Abstract
Antiviral drugs are among the few countermeasures available during the critical interval between the emergence of a novel influenza pandemic and vaccine availability. Antiviral stockpiling is a key pandemic preparedness measure, yet existing stockpiling estimates vary widely and rest on outdated assumptions about healthcare-seeking behaviour and drug-specific effectiveness – limitations that the COVID-19 pandemic and recent clinical trial evidence have made untenable. We developed a multi-scale transmission model incorporating heterogeneous healthcare-seeking behaviour and the first direct clinical estimates of antiviral transmission risk reduction to estimate country-specific demand and mortality impact across four pandemic scenarios in 186 countries. We find that baloxavir marboxil (BXM), due to its transmission-reducing potential, could avert 37– 68% of mean pandemic deaths in the first epidemic wave, approximately double the impact of oseltamivir, while requiring a mean stockpile approximately 5–10% smaller (7–34% of the population, compared to 28–36% for oseltamivir). Uncertainty in viral load dynamics and transmission reduction benefits from clinical trials means that BXM’s impact could vary, but sensitivity analyses consistently suggest that BXM is likely to be more effective than oseltamivir. Under limited drug availability, priority should be given to treatment over post-exposure prophylaxis. Although drug rationing for high-mortality populations (e.g. elderly) can substantially reduce BXM demand, doing so leads to greater total pandemic deaths. Critically, each week of delay in initiating antiviral distribution erodes impact by up to 3% of averted deaths, meaning that antiviral stockpiles must be accompanied by rapid deployment infrastructure to deliver their potential impact.
Significance Statement
Pandemic preparedness requires strategic stockpiling of antiviral drugs but existing stockpile estimates are based on oversimplified assumptions about healthcare-seeking behavior and drug effectiveness. This study develops a new mathematical model incorporating realistic healthcare-seeking patterns and drug-specific transmission risk reduction when considering antiviral stockpile planning for influenza pandemics across 186 countries. We find that baloxavir marboxil could prevent nearly twice as many deaths as oseltamivir while requiring smaller stockpiles. Under limited drug supply, treatment should be prioritised over prophylaxis, and age-based rationing for high-mortality populations would not reduce total pandemic deaths. These insights provide evidence-based guidance for national antiviral drugs stockpiling strategies as part of preparedness efforts for future influenza pandemics.
