Integrating intraspecific variation into population dynamics reveals how interacting species persist in mutualistic communities

Mutualistic interactions among organisms are fundamental to the origin and maintenance of bio-diversity. Yet, the study of community dynamics often relies on species-level values, ignoring the effects of intraspecific variation. We propose a theoretical framework for evaluating the extent to which variation within populations can influence species’ persistence in mutualistic systems. Next, drawing from detailed empirical data on plant–pollinator interactions and plant fitness, we quantify intraspecific variation in the mutualistic benefits received by plants and incorporate this variation into estimations of structural stability, a robust theoretical measure of species’ likelihood of persistence. Through explicit consideration of intraspecific variation, we demonstrate that, in the absence of heterospecific plant competitors, plant populations composed of specialized individuals promote the persistence of the plant species they belong to and their associated pollinator community. However, these positive effects do not hold when plant species compete with a broader plant community. In this case, having more heterogeneous mixtures of plant individuals (i.e., both specialized and generalized) is more beneficial for a population’s persistence. By integrating the proposed framework with empirical data, we are able to explicitly account for individual-level variation, opening the door to a better understanding of the mechanisms promoting biodiversity in mutualistic communities.