A natural ANI gap that can define intra-species units of bacteriophages and other viruses
Listed in
This article is not in any list yet, why not save it to one of your lists.Abstract
Despite the importance of intra-species variants of viruses for causing disease and/or disrupting ecosystem functioning, there is no universally applicable standard to define these. A 95% whole-genome average nucleotide identity (ANI) gap is commonly used to define species, especially for bacteriophages, but whether a similar gap exists within species that can be used to define intra-species units has not been evaluated yet. Whole-genome comparisons among members of 1,016 bacteriophage species revealed a region of low frequency of pairs around 99.2-99.8% ANI, showing 3-fold or fewer pairs than expected for an even or normal distribution. This second gap is prevalent in viruses infecting various cultured or uncultured hosts, and from a variety of environments, although a few exceptions to this pattern were also observed (∼3.7% of the total species evaluated) and are likely attributed to cultivation biases. Similar results were observed for a limited set of eukaryotic viruses that are adequately sampled including SARS-CoV-2, whose ANI-based clusters matched well the WHO-defined Variants of Concern, indicating that they represent functionally and/or ecologically distinct units. The existence of sequence-discrete units appears to be predominantly driven by (high) ecological cohesiveness coupled to either recombination frequency for bacteriophages or selection and clonal evolution for other viruses such as SARS-CoV-2. These results indicate that fundamentally different underlying mechanisms could lead to similar diversity patterns. Based on these results, we propose the 99.5% ANI as a practical, standardized, and data-supported threshold for defining viral intra-species units of bacteriophages, for which we propose the term genomovars.
Importance
Viral species are composed of an ensemble of intra-species variants whose dynamic may have major implications for human and animal health and/or ecosystem functioning. However, the lack of universally-accepted standards to define these intra-species variants has led researchers to use different approaches for this task, creating inconsistent intra-species units across different viral families and confusion in communication. By comparing hundreds of viral bacteriophage genomes, we show that there is a nearly universal natural gap in whole-genome average nucleotide identities (ANI) among genomes at around 99.5%, which can be used to define intra-species units. Therefore, these results advance the molecular toolbox for tracking viral intra-species units and should facilitate future epidemiological and environmental studies.
