Mouse model of anti-RANKL discontinuation reveals reduced bone mass and quality through disruption of bone remodeling

The discontinuation of denosumab [antibody targeting receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa B ligand (RANKL)] therapy may increase the risk of multiple vertebral fractures; however, the underlying pathophysiology is largely unknown. In patients who underwent discontinuation after multiple injections of denosumab, the levels of tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase 5b increased compared to pretreatment levels, indicating a phenomenon known as “overshoot.” The rate of decrease in bone mineral density during the withdrawal period was higher than the rate of decrease associated with aging, suggesting that the physiological bone metabolism had broken down. Overshoot and significant bone loss were also observed in mice receiving continuous administration of anti-RANKL antibody after treatment was interrupted, resembling the original pathology. In mice long out of overshoot, bone resorption recovered, but osteoblast numbers and bone formation remained markedly reduced. The bone marrow exhibited a significant reduction in stem cell (SC) antigen 1- and platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha-expressing osteoblast progenitors (PαS cells) and alkaline phosphatase-positive early osteoblasts. Just before the overshoot phase, the osteoclast precursor cell population expands and RANKL-bearing extracellular vesicles (EVs) became abundant in the serum, leading to robust osteoclastogenesis after cessation of anti-RANKL treatment. Thus, accelerated bone resorption due to the accumulation of RANKL-bearing EVs and long-term suppression of bone formation uncoupled from bone resorption leads to the severe bone loss characteristic of denosumab discontinuation.