Environmental impacts on gene expression noise and its relationship with fitness

Genetically identical cells grown in the same environment show variation in gene expression known as expression noise. Expression noise can be heritable and impact fitness, making it subject to natural selection. Increasing expression noise for the Saccharomyces cerevisiae TDH3 gene was shown to be beneficial in glucose-based media when mean TDH3 expression was far from the fitness optimum but deleterious when it was close to this optimum. Here, we show that growth on different carbon sources alters the effects of new mutations on TDH3 expression noise and examine the fitness effects of changing expression noise. In galactose-based media, we observed the same relationship between expression noise and fitness seen in glucose-based media, but in glycerol- and ethanol-based media, we observed the opposite relationship or no significant relationship, respectively. Using simulations of single-cell organisms, we found that these differences were most likely explained by environment-specific relationships between gene expression and fitness. We also found that, far from the optimum, the fitness effects of noise were greatest when expression was highly heritable between mother and daughter cells. The empirical observations and simulations reported in this study show how environments influence both the production of expression noise and its impacts on fitness.