The impact of Cronartium ribicola inoculum density on quantitative disease resistance in whitebark pine

Whitebark pine ( Pinus albicaulis ), a wide-ranging high-elevation conifer in western North America, is listed as threatened in the U.S. and as endangered in Canada. A major threat to whitebark pine is the non-native, invasive white pine blister rust disease, caused by the fungal pathogen Cronartium ribicola . In many pathosystems (including white pine blister rust), seedling inoculation trials are used to identify parent trees with genetic resistance. However, many of these trials use only one spore density for inoculation, and little information exists on the effectiveness of quantitative disease resistance (QDR) under varying spore densities and the corresponding implications for field performance. In this study, we examine the levels of infection and survival present within six whitebark pine seedling families previously rated for QDR (three susceptible and three resistant families) under six widely varying inoculum densities. The susceptible families showed very high infection and mortality at all inoculum densities, while performance of the resistant families varied with spore density treatment. The information gathered from the study will be useful in updating the projections of the future of whitebark pine populations under field conditions in areas of different rust hazard. The results also serve as a caution to those working in other pathosystems where seedling inoculation trials based on one spore density level are used to rate the resistance level of parent trees and their associated progeny.